Number 1!
To start, my number 1 favorite creppy pasta is the Minecraft "John" creepypasta. Its simple, pretty goofy at times, but affective. It feels weirldy like it could happen in real life (other than the friend dying thing) and the pictures used with it are amazing.
Number 2!
This one might be a weird choice, but my 2nd favorite is Sonic.EXE! This one is mainly because its goofy tho, but also because it spawned some of the most creative sonic horror media ive seen (like Lord X, Sonic.ERR, Tails doll... arguably, and all those fnf mods XD)
Number 3!
Next up, another sonic creepypasta. Pendrive azul is my 3rd favorite because of how real it feels, this time not in the way of John. I feel like someone could actually have made a sonic fan game that gave people seizures, plus all the recreations of it look great! Great story with even better recreations (sometimes)
Number 4!
Forth, Lost Silver. This one is only because i have fond memories of the story from when i was younger. (unrestricted internet accsess is great isnt it...) its not my favorite, not by a long shot, but its alright... weirdly, John and Sonic.EXE are arguably better! mainly cause of the creativity they bred.
Number 5!
This one might be a bit weird, but, virtually any ROBLOX creepypasta/arg. They all follow a bit of the same format (arg's especially >.>) but theyre always fun to play around with and make (kinda) your own. Some of my favorites include Noli, Ihasafacelulz, and 1x1x1x1. Im only now realizing that i have 2 "weird choices," but i dont really care tbh...